Over these past two months, I’ve had the opportunity to review the first three chapters of over thirty manuscripts as well as half a dozen full drafts. These submissions had interesting themes, strong settings, and likable characters, but many shared the same issue: a lack of structure.

While I am no stranger to reading and providing feedback on manuscripts for fellow writers, this is the first time I’ve done it at this scale, with a publisher and editor hat on. The process has surprised me. We received submissions from individuals with college writing degrees as well as some from people with more informal experience. The mechanical aspects of the work from both backgrounds were solid, but I still found myself struggling to fully engage with the story, and this is why structure is so key. Stories have to be more than clearly written sentences and a collection of characters to which things happen in an interesting setting. Engaging narratives are patterns that our brains recognize, process for meaning, and commit to memory. They are structured in a specific manner.

I’m not going to get into a lot of detail, because there are thousands of different writing craft books on structure—three-act, four-act, the hero’s journey, genre-specific beat writing—and you really just need to pick one and apply it. My personal recommendation is Save the Cat! Writes a Novel.

The rest of this article covers some practical craft tips for the first 10 to 20% of a novel. My philosophy here is that if a writer can nail the first act of their manuscript in terms of structure, they’ve built a strong foundation for the rest of the novel.

Establishing the World

While this may seem like a given to some, many writers have different interpretations of what this means, so I’ll be straightforward:

Show the main character (protagonist) actively doing something that is common for them in a place (setting) that is familiar to them.

Whatever your main character is doing should be, ideally, surprising or at least situationally interesting to the reader. The secondary function of establishing the world is to serve as a hook that engages the reader.

My personal suggestions for world establishment would be to avoid:

  • Prologues—they distract from the present world

  • Info dumps/excessive inner monologue—they’re boring and tell rather than show

  • POV shifts—they’re confusing and take focus away from the protagonist

Character Want Versus Need

The protagonist’s arc, in its rawest form, is what the character wants, and this should never be left open to interpretation. The reader should clearly understand what the character wants as soon as possible.

To contrast what they want, what the protagonist actually needs should immediately follow and be made relatively obvious. Often, what the protagonist needs is literally told to them by another character, but it can also take the form of sarcastic self-criticism, a sign (literal or figurative), or some other external implication, verbalized or delivered symbolically.

Surprisingly, there is a lot of freedom in how the writer can convey the protagonist’s wants and needs. The key is to make them clear as soon as possible, but absolutely no later than the 20% point of the novel (which is the approximate end of the first act using a three-act structure).

What the protagonist wants should always be in contrast to what they need. Needs should never sit adjacent to or identical with what they want. A need that is too similar or adjacent to the protagonist’s want will cause structural issues in the back half of the story exactly because there is no contrast.

To give an example of myself as the protagonist of my story: I want to earn a ten-figure salary writing fiction revered by millions worldwide. Then I can buy a private island in Fiji and build a secret volcano lair and my own private zoo. But my actual need is to feel like my work is satisfying and that I’m a valuable member of my community. As with that want-versus-need example, they often contrast in that wants are very specific and temporarily appealing, while needs are more big-picture and long-term.

Pulling in ten figures and getting the recognition of a bestseller may seem like it will make me very happy, but it won’t directly translate to feeling satisfied with my work, nor will it grant me the sense that I’m contributing to my community. And in fact, blindly pursuing that want conflicts with that need in several ways—the focus could draw me away from the personal relationships that cement me to my community, and my money could isolate me from them, causing me to always wonder who truly respects me and who just wants something from me. Most of you probably get how the evil genie thing works.

How the Setup Pays Off

In most story structure models, the bulk of the entertaining stuff happens between the 21% and 50% points. It’s here that the protagonist is thrown out of their comfort zone, and crazy things start to happen. In my example, I finally get my manuscript in front of a top-notch agent.

In other stories, maybe the protagonist gets whatever they want, and their decisions lead them to fun and games. Maybe it’s when they start putting the mystery together. Maybe things go terribly wrong, and every decision they make is about survival. Whatever it is, the unexpected happens, leading us towards the inevitable conflict.

But let’s think about why the 21 to 50% section of the story is so exciting: it’s because everything is happening in contrast to the world we were just living in! For the first 20% of the story, we hung out with our new bestie, the protagonist, and learned all about their wants and their needs! And then it all gets thrown topsy-turvy. Exciting.

For my example, by the midpoint I’m making ten figures as a fiction writer, and it’s awesome. So I move out of Texas, buy my own island in Fiji, and build my secret volcano lair and private zoo.

If you hung out with me in that first part, you were my cheerleader as I worked hard to be discovered by my agent, then my manuscript was purchased by a Big Five publisher, and ultimately optioned for what became an award-winning blockbuster movie. Granted, I had to sacrifice time spent with my community of friends and family, but it’s all worth it when it pays off, right? Volcano lair! Private zoo! I fly everyone to come visit me! Things have changed since I began my climb to literary stardom, though, and while my friends and family have fun at my private island zoo, this is not their life. I overhear them planning their flights home. They have to leave after a few days. Their lives don’t make sense with my life anymore, and now I have to decide… what is more important? The Fijian paradise, or my community and place within it? The story essentially writes itself now that I’ve done all the setup.

But what if you did not hang out with me and learn my wants and needs? What if you just watched me go through a couple of weeks of my life without ever really getting into any of that? If I did not set up the first 20%, you, as the reader, aren’t really sure where all of this is going. Maybe I still get the billions in royalties, build the zoo and the volcano lair, and it’s kind of fun to watch—but is that even what I, as the protagonist, wanted? What was the point of any of it? Just to show it’s fun to be rich and have a volcano lair? Did you need to read twelve thousand words to know that?

This late into the story, options become limited. If I, as the protagonist, now try to tell the readers that I’ve gotten everything I’ve ever wanted, it’s too late. They didn’t get to watch me get it, even though they knew how much I wanted it. They only found out after the fact! What’s worse, they’re still not sure what I need, which makes it difficult for them to consider what I, as the protagonist, ought to do. Now that I’m a wealthy and famous author who owns a Fijian volcano lair, who is going to sympathize with me when I tell them I’m unhappy?

The story problems snowball, and even when the writer has the components of a really entertaining story, the execution is such that those components never land coherently and satisfyingly for the reader.

After the 50% point, the story usually deals with conflict and the decisions the character makes to try to resolve it towards a climax. A necessary condition for conflict is that two or more parties want contrasting outcomes—one of those parties being the protagonist. Again, we’re going back to the protagonist’s wants and needs. If we don’t have those, we don’t have the fuel for the contrast because, even if we see the outcome the protagonist is attempting to achieve, we haven’t experienced what is at stake for them. We also don’t know the lesson that the protagonist needs to learn. Everything in the back half of the book depends upon what you did in the first 20%.

It’s Only 20%

While I’m confident that a good first-act setup makes all stories better, please keep in mind that there is still the other 80% of the story to consider. Character arcs, themes, tension, and pacing all rely on structure, and there are nuances to these that aren’t always intuitive. I think some authors avoid deep dives into structure because they believe that too much focus on structure will make their stories predictable, but I strongly believe the opposite is true; a master of structure will understand what’s needed for the story and what’s expected by the reader. As you continue to hone your craft, understanding the framework that drives your story forward will empower you to manipulate plot and character in unique and interesting ways that will surprise your readers.

Easy to Fix

If you think your own manuscript may be suffering from the issues I’ve outlined, the good news is that it is often relatively easy to fix. Most human beings more or less have an idea of how a story needs to be told because, as I’ve touched on, narrative is a human tool that is hardwired into us. In most of the manuscripts I’ve read over the past two months, the elements of structure are there within what is already written, and they just need to be brought forward earlier and more obviously. I encourage you to reread your existing draft and focus on characters’ wants and needs, and assess whether you are clearly conveying those to the reader within the first 20% of your novel. If you find that you are not, you may be surprised at how significantly you can improve the draft by just adding a little structure.

Here are a few story structure books that we recommend: